CD
Although Rossini’s Stabat Mater would never be mistaken for one of the composer’s many jovial operas, it still wears its piety rather lightly. One of only a handful of sacred scores by Rossini, it is a gorgeous setting for four soloists, chorus, and orchestra of the heartrending story of Mary before the Cross. And while it contains moments that point toward the dramatic strength of Verdi’s Requiem, it also -- Rossini being Rossini -- is filled with one beguiling and charming melody after another. This poses an interpretive challenge: In the wrong hands, the Stabat Mater can come off as an unfortunate mix of the solemn and the lighthearted. But happily, conductor Riccardo Chailly makes a perfect diplomat. He finds middle ground by not overemphasizing the blithe character of much of the music -- and thus making it sound frivolous -- while at the same time not charging the score with a dramatic burden it can’t bear. It’s also fortunate that he has the world-class forces of the Concertgebouw Orchestra at his command; their playing is superior throughout. And the Netherlands Radio Choir sings with commitment and distinction. The soloists are also strong, though certainly not A-list. Soprano Barbara Frittoli can stray from the center of the pitch when singing sotto voce, yet she is also capable of beautiful, lustrous singing, and her "Inflammatus est" is suitably stirring, with ringing high notes at the end. Lighter voiced, Giuseppe Sabbatini pulls of the lilting tenor aria "Cuius animam" in impeccable bel canto style, while bass Michele Pertusi offers a lyrical "Pro peccatis," and mezzo Sonia Ganassi supplies a touching "Fac ut portem." Standing strong alongside the worthy competition from Hickox and Chung, this is one of the most persuasive performances on disc of this wonderful but deceptively tricky music. EJ Johnson, Barnes & Noble