Barnes & Noble
Not entirely a greatest-hits package, Jars of Clay's newest is a 2-CD set consisting of 11 live recordings, plus acoustic
reworkings of eight big hits and two new tracks.. One gets the sense that the Jars guys really just
wanted to tinker with all that new studio equipment they bought to
record The Eleventh Hour, though, and these tracks are really for the Jars completist. The acoustic tracks are sparse,
mostly featuring Dan Haseltine's vocals and simple guitar, with few
background vocals or other instrumentation. This is fine on a simple
ballad like "Needful Hands," but "Liquid," which was such perfection in its original
form, lacks spark. New tracks "The Valley Song (Sing of Your Mercy)" and "Dig"
are slow, intriguing ballads that would benefit from a little more production. Things get
jazzed up considerably on the live end, with rocking takes on
signature hits "Disappear," "Like a Child," and "Flood." Jars have
always been an energetic live band, and it's here that
Furthermore wakes from its acoustic slumber and sizzles. Fans
who enjoy hearing the live Jars can get more with the
group's 11 Live: Jars of Clay in Concert DVD, which contains
versions of several big hits not offered here -- "Collide" and "Unforgetful You," to name two. Lisa Zhito
All Music Guide
With four studio releases to its credit, Jars of Clay returns with Furthermore, a two-disc set that features a disc of live material plus an entire disc of reworked material and three new tracks. One could be a bit apprehensive about a band whose sound is already traditionally "unplugged" and stripped down to begin with. How could a band like this rework songs and offer anything new to the listener? Starting with the "From the Studio" disc, the band kicks things off with its mega hit, "Overjoyed." Stripped down and laid-back, the Jars add a jazzy piano to the mix, changing the complexion of the song completely. "Liquid" is transformed with elegance and grace. The cut's prior mode featured violins and chants kick-starting the intro, while the latter uses pianos and acoustic guitars to turn the cut into a moving, emotional ballad. "Dig" is one of the new tunes on the release. Originally done by Adam Again, the song has a somber vibe that sends the listener into a melancholy orbit, truly stirring the soul. Other cuts of note from the studio disc include "Love Song for a Savior," which retains the singalong qualities of the original while breaking into a Seals & Crofts mode on the verse, and "Frail," which reflects its predecessor but becomes much richer with the acoustics and vocals out front. What you get with the studio disc is a coffeehouse vibe that exudes coolness. It's truly Jars of Clay at its finest moment.
The second disc ("From the Stage") features the band live from its Eleventh Hour tour. Cuts like "Disappear" and "Crazy Times" translate well into the live setting. Vocalist Dan Haseltine had developed stronger chops over the previous few years, helping to breed cuts full of energy and flavor, while guitarist Matt Odmark blazes midsong on "Crazy Times." "I'm Alright" is a cut with energy and funk. The tune bolsters incredibly soulful background vocals while keyboardist Charlie Lowell uses his Hammond B-3 to bring the cut into the sanctuary with gospel flair. "Flood" is the band's crowning achievement as a live concert staple. The Jars play the tune very close to the vest. The complexities and orchestral bridge of "Flood" are enough to warrant the tune as is, and the band pulls it off flawlessly. Furthermore is a disc that does not come off as a collection of retreads, but as a crowning achievement for the fans. On one hand you're pulled into the most intimate of coffeehouses for disc one, while soaking up the energy of an outstanding live performance on disc two. Truly the best of both worlds. ~ Steven Douglas Losey, All Music Guide