New York Times
An exciting addition to the catalog.... The Munich Philharmonic sounds terrific. The playing is vibrant, secure and sonorous.... The symphony seems at once more lucid than in many performances yet volatile, menacing and triumphant.
Anthony Tommasini
Gramophone
This Thielemann performance [of the "Egmont" Overture] is exceptional.... The Brahms is even more unashamedly "old school," painted from a full, dark palette of sound colours, richly applied and finely blended after the manner of the great colourists of the past. Richard Osborne
BBC Music Magazine



Opulently recorded, involving performances.... Every bar is carefully nuanced, the orchestra responding quite splendidly. Erik Levi
Daily Telegraph
The performance proves that, even in a world changed for ever by the period-instrument movement, there is a place for this grandiose and assertive kind of music-making.
Matthew Rye