One of their bestby JohnQ

Reader Rating:
See Detailed Ratings

July 30, 2009: Despite the absence of Rodger Waters this is one of Pink Floyd's best albums. One terrific song after another.

Roger needs a good kick in the...by Anonymous

Reader Rating:
See Detailed Ratings

February 18, 2006: Well, Floyd defied the odds, even after Roger's split. A bit of history: after the Final Cut, Roger publicly announced the Floyd was over, because they were creatively exhausted and drained. Despite the failure of The Final Cut, Nick and David thought otherwise. They continued Floyd on their own terms. One obstacle left: Roger sued, claiming the name belonged only to him. The just government of England saw it differently, and allowed them to continue. A delicate and mellow release, some of the band's most well-liked songs exist here, surprisingly, such as "Learning to Fly", "On the Turning Away", and "Sorrow". Heralded by critics, and shunned by Roger as a "clever forgery," this will never die.

This review was written about the CD edition.